| Best-selling Cakes & Balsamics bundle -- Black Cat Special | blackcatcafes.com | 84 USD | — | — |
| Holiday Gift Baskets | blackcatcafes.com | 79 USD | — | — |
| Cooking Class, Lebanese Dinner! | blackcatcafes.com | 75 USD | — | — |
| Cooking Classes Private 2026, Hands-on, limited to 4* | blackcatcafes.com | 65 USD | — | — |
| Black Cat Balsamics & Condiments — set of 6 — Special | blackcatcafes.com | 59 USD | — | — |
| Sampler Set - 5 Black Cat Balsamics plus NEW Balsamic Book | blackcatcafes.com | 55 USD | — | — |
| Cooking Classes 2026 | blackcatcafes.com | 45 USD | — | — |
| Organic cotton apron | blackcatcafes.com | 40 USD | — | — |
| Sampler Set -3 Black Cat Balsamics 5 oz plus NEW Balsamic Book | blackcatcafes.com | 36 USD | — | — |
| Dr. Jane's Rx FLIGHT of Hot Sauce minis | blackcatcafes.com | 36 USD | — | — |
| Lebanese Holiday Special | blackcatcafes.com | 36 USD | — | — |
| Generous Blonde Fruitcake original | blackcatcafes.com | 33 USD | — | — |
| Gluten-Free Drunken Blonde Fruitcake | blackcatcafes.com | 33 USD | — | — |
| Drunken Blonde Fruitcake | blackcatcafes.com | 30 USD | — | — |
| Unisex Sweatshirt | blackcatcafes.com | 27 USD | — | — |
| Sharon Springs Waters 170th anniversary edition | blackcatcafes.com | 25 USD | — | — |
| Flight of Black Cat Balsamics | blackcatcafes.com | 20 USD | — | — |
| Black Cat classic tee in Gray | blackcatcafes.com | 20 USD | — | — |
| The Ultimate GLUTEN FREE Fruitcake NEW! | blackcatcafes.com | 20 USD | — | — |
| Ultimate Fruitcake | blackcatcafes.com | 20 USD | — | — |
| Pineapple Cherry Cake | blackcatcafes.com | 18 USD | — | — |
| Sugar Plums... authentic confections. Vegan & gluten-free | blackcatcafes.com | 15 USD | — | — |
| COCOA Plums... chocolatey confections. vegan & gluten-free | blackcatcafes.com | 15 USD | — | — |
| Dr. Jane's Rx Hot Sauce 5 oz | blackcatcafes.com | 15 USD | — | — |
| Fig Balsamic Drizzle LIMITED EDITION cork bottle from Spain | blackcatcafes.com | 13 USD | — | — |
| Figs Preserved in Balsamic | blackcatcafes.com | 12 USD | — | — |
| Mediterranean Lemon Dressing | blackcatcafes.com | 12 USD | — | — |
| Garlic Balsamic Drizzle | blackcatcafes.com | 12 USD | — | — |
| Coconut Macaroons gluten-free | blackcatcafes.com | 12 USD | — | — |
| Black Hot Sauce | blackcatcafes.com | 10.2 USD | — | — |
| Ghost Pepper Salt | blackcatcafes.com | 10 USD | — | — |
| Rosemary Salt by Dr. Jane's Rx | blackcatcafes.com | 10 USD | — | — |
| Black Cat Gift Card | blackcatcafes.com | 10 USD | — | — |
| Cake Bites | blackcatcafes.com | 9 USD | — | — |
| Pomegranate Molasses, Al Wadi, Lebanese | blackcatcafes.com | 9 USD | — | — |
| Rose Water, Al Wadi, Lebanese | blackcatcafes.com | 9 USD | — | — |
| Orange Flower Water, Al Wadi, Lebanese | blackcatcafes.com | 9 USD | — | — |
| Dr. Jane's Rx Hot Sauce mini in 6 colors! | blackcatcafes.com | 6 USD | — | — |
| Fig Balsamic Drizzle mini sampler | blackcatcafes.com | 6 USD | — | — |
| Black & White Balsamic | blackcatcafes.com | 6 USD | — | — |