| Stephen Sondheim Sweeney Todd inspired Embroidered Apron | cratejoy.com | 30 USD | — | — |
| Tony Award-inspired Silver-Plated Medallion | cratejoy.com | 20.0 USD | — | — |
| Stars and the Moon USB Light - Now 20% off! | cratejoy.com | 20 USD | — | — |
| Six-inspired Acrylic Stand | cratejoy.com | 20 USD | — | — |
| Rent-inspired Pocketwatch | cratejoy.com | 20 USD | — | — |
| Jagged Little Pill inspired Tablet Bag - Now 20% Off - Everything's Gonna Be Fine Fine Fine | cratejoy.com | 20 USD | — | — |
| Into the Woods inspired Milky White Metal Bookmark | cratejoy.com | 20 USD | 20 USD | — |
| In The Heights inspired 96000 Beach Throw Towel - Now discounted! | cratejoy.com | 19.96 USD | — | — |
| A Strange Loop Broadway Musical inspired engraved Necklace - Inner White Girl - Rose Gold Ring on Chain | cratejoy.com | 15 USD | 15 USD | — |
| Hamilton-inspired - Raise a Glass to Freedom Ceramic Mug - Now $5 off! | cratejoy.com | 15 USD | — | — |
| Kinky Boots-inspired PRIDE 3D Magnet | cratejoy.com | 15 USD | — | — |
| Angels in America-inspired Pouch | cratejoy.com | 12 USD | — | — |
| You Go Glen Coco Enamel Pin | cratejoy.com | 12 USD | — | — |
| Moulin Rouge inspired leather pocket mirror | cratejoy.com | 12 USD | — | — |
| Hauntingly Broadway Halloween Musical Charm Candy Bag Keychain | cratejoy.com | 12 USD | — | — |
| The Inheritance-inspired Embroidered Patch | cratejoy.com | 12 USD | — | — |
| Beetlejuice-inspired Enamel Pin | cratejoy.com | 12 USD | 12 USD | — |
| Broadway Souvenir License Plate | cratejoy.com | 12 USD | — | — |
| Little Shop of Horror's inspired Acrylic Keychain | cratejoy.com | 11 USD | — | — |
| In The Heights Inspired Paciencia y Fe Wooden Sign | cratejoy.com | 10.96 USD | — | — |
| Hadestown inspired "Orpheus' Box" Wooden Box | cratejoy.com | 10 USD | — | — |
| Dear Evan Hansen-inspired Embroidered Keychain | cratejoy.com | 10 USD | — | — |
| Metal Broadway Sign Street Sign | cratejoy.com | 10 USD | — | — |
| Places Please, Broadway's Back Acrylic Magnet | cratejoy.com | 10 USD | — | — |
| Boxed Up Broadway Silhouette Water Bottle - Discounted! | cratejoy.com | 10 USD | — | — |
| Beetlejuice inspired "Buy More Crystals" Glass Water Bottle - New Discounted Price! | cratejoy.com | 10 USD | — | — |
| TINA - The Tina Turner Musical inspired 3D Luggage Tag | cratejoy.com | 10 USD | — | — |
| Dear Evan Hansen inspired Window Sticker Cling | cratejoy.com | 6 USD | — | — |
| SECONDS SALE: Stephen Sondheim Sundae in the Park with George Snack Cup | cratejoy.com | 5 USD | — | — |
| August Wilson First Day Stamp Envelope | cratejoy.com | 5 USD | — | — |
| Gift-Wrap your Order | cratejoy.com | 4.49 USD | — | — |