| Cyrus & Klara Premium Tournament Collection sealed case | caffeinecritical.com | 2118 USD | — | — |
| Runar Deluxe Bundle | caffeinecritical.com | 1322 USD | — | — |
| Zombicide Frozen Fortress Expansion | caffeinecritical.com | 708 USD | — | — |
| Runar Jarl Expansion | caffeinecritical.com | 284 USD | — | — |
| Disney Loungefly Princess Hip Bag | caffeinecritical.com | 284 USD | — | — |
| Lord of the Rings The Card Game Revised Core Set | LCG | caffeinecritical.com | 283 USD | — | — |
| Pokemon Glory of Team Rocket Booster Box Korean | caffeinecritical.com | 245 USD | — | — |
| The Academic 133+ Teal/Pink | caffeinecritical.com | 236 USD | — | — |
| Runar Hel Expansion | caffeinecritical.com | 236 USD | — | — |
| 2022 Pokemon SWSH Ultra Ball Brilliant Stars Secret | PSA 10 Gem Mint | caffeinecritical.com | 236 USD | — | — |
| Waifu Hentai Mystery Box | Monthly Subscription Discount! | caffeinecritical.com | 218 USD | — | — |
| Star Wars Disney Loungefly Mandalorian Backpack | caffeinecritical.com | 213 USD | — | — |
| Pokemon Scarlet & Violet Battle Partners Booster Box Korean | caffeinecritical.com | 212 USD | — | — |
| Carcassonne: Build, Compete & Conquer in the Epic Tile Game! | caffeinecritical.com | 199 USD | — | — |
| Hibachi | caffeinecritical.com | 189 USD | — | — |
| Lord of the Rings Duel for Middle Earth | caffeinecritical.com | 189 USD | — | — |
| 2005 Pokemon EX Emerald Illumise Rev. Holo| SGC 8 Graded | caffeinecritical.com | 189 USD | — | — |
| Zip-Up Album 18-Pocket Yellow | caffeinecritical.com | 166 USD | — | — |
| Zip-Up Album 18-Pocket Pink | caffeinecritical.com | 166 USD | — | — |
| Zip-Up Album 18 Pocket Green | caffeinecritical.com | 166 USD | — | — |
| OverPower TCG Power Card Station | caffeinecritical.com | 166 USD | — | — |
| Zip-Up Album 18-Pocket Purple | caffeinecritical.com | 165 USD | — | — |
| Full Glory Waifus: Summer Love Collection Box | Hentai Waifu Trading Cards | caffeinecritical.com | 160 USD | — | — |
| Star Wars Mandalorian Hip Bag | caffeinecritical.com | 151 USD | — | — |
| Heroes of Might and Magic 3 the Board Game - Tower Expansion & Stretch Goals | Gamefound Exclusive | caffeinecritical.com | 149.99 USD | — | — |
| Star Wars: Shatterpoint Core Set | Miniatures Skirmish Game | caffeinecritical.com | 143.95 USD | — | — |
| Level Ball Pokemon Battle Styles 2021 | CGC 9.5 Gem Mint | caffeinecritical.com | 142 USD | — | — |
| Zip-Up Album 18 Pocket: Black Binder | caffeinecritical.com | 142 USD | — | — |
| Drinking Quest: Belch of the Wild | caffeinecritical.com | 142 USD | — | — |
| Heroes of Might and Magic 3 the Board Game | Gamefound Exclusive | caffeinecritical.com | 134.99 USD | — | — |
| Prime Album 18-Pocket Pink | caffeinecritical.com | 133 USD | — | — |
| Prime Album 18-Pocket Purple | caffeinecritical.com | 133 USD | — | — |
| Prime Album 18-Pocket Yellow | caffeinecritical.com | 133 USD | — | — |
| Heroes of Might and Magic 3 the Board Game - Crystal Stretch Goals | Gamefound Exclusive | caffeinecritical.com | 129.99 USD | — | — |
| Heroes of Might and Magic 3 the Board Game - Stretch Goals Props and Neutral Units | Gamefound Exclusive | caffeinecritical.com | 128.99 USD | — | — |
| Marvel United: Infinity Gauntlet Expansion - Tabletop Miniatures Strategy Game, Cooperative Superhero Game | caffeinecritical.com | 123.95 USD | — | — |
| Zip-Up Album 8-Pocket Pink | caffeinecritical.com | 123 USD | — | — |
| Prime Album 18 Pocket: Black Binder | caffeinecritical.com | 118 USD | — | — |
| Army of The Dead - A Zombicide Game Join The Mercenaries in a Heist Through Zombie-Infested Las Vegas! | caffeinecritical.com | 117.95 USD | — | — |
| Halo: Flashpoint - Spartan Edition | Tactical Miniatures Game | caffeinecritical.com | 116.95 USD | — | — |