| Cinco de Mayo Sampler | cigarclub.com | 45 USD | 65 USD | −30.8% |
| Fratello Lunar Gift Set | cigarclub.com | 69.99 USD | 89.99 USD | −22.2% |
| Florida Habano Toro | cigarclub.com | 67 USD | 335 USD | −15.2% |
| LSU Connecticut Toro | cigarclub.com | 67 USD | 335 USD | −14.3% |
| LSU Habano Toro | cigarclub.com | 67 USD | 335 USD | −14.3% |
| Cigar Gift Box - Corporate/Bulk Gifting | cigarclub.com | 50 USD | 135 USD | −11.9% |
| CigarClub BLACK Membership | cigarclub.com | 59 USD | 118 USD | −7.6% |
| Mississippi State Pinstripe Signature Edition | cigarclub.com | 71 USD | 355 USD | −5.6% |
| 2026 CigarClub Explorer Annual Pre-Pay | cigarclub.com | 419.99 USD | — | — |
| CigarClub Customs - Annual Gift | cigarclub.com | 329 USD | — | — |
| 7th Anniversary Pre-Pay Event [Get 2 Months FREE] | cigarclub.com | 299 USD | — | — |
| Explorer Subscription Gift - 10/Mo | cigarclub.com | 289 USD | — | — |
| Cigar Subscription Gift - 10 Cigars/Month | cigarclub.com | 249.99 USD | — | — |
| CigarClub BLACK - Annual Gift | cigarclub.com | 239 USD | — | — |
| Explorer Subscription Gift - 5/Mo | cigarclub.com | 169 USD | — | — |
| Cigar Subscription Gift - 5 Cigars/Month | cigarclub.com | 139.99 USD | — | — |
| La Palina - Reserva 723 Exclusive | 5 Pack | cigarclub.com | 115 USD | — | — |
| Explorer Subscription Gift - 3/Mo | cigarclub.com | 109 USD | — | — |
| Cigar Subscription Gift - 3 Cigars/Month | cigarclub.com | 99.99 USD | — | — |
| CigarClub Gift Set: Torch Lighter + Porcelain Ashtray | cigarclub.com | 99 USD | — | — |
| Exclusive Leather Cigar Case | cigarclub.com | 99 USD | — | — |
| Explorer Gift Redemption - 10/mo | cigarclub.com | 94.83 USD | — | — |
| Caldwell 5-Cigar Sampler and Travel Humidor | cigarclub.com | 85 USD | — | — |
| Aganorsa Guardian of The Farm: Ranger [CigarClub Exclusive] | cigarclub.com | 80 USD | — | — |
| October 2022 Top 10 Cigar Sampler | cigarclub.com | 75 USD | — | — |
| Tea Collection Box | cigarclub.com | 75 USD | — | — |
| July 2022 Top 10 Cigar Sampler | cigarclub.com | 75 USD | — | — |
| Texas A&M Connecticut Toro | cigarclub.com | 72 USD | — | — |
| Texas A&M Habano Toro | cigarclub.com | 72 USD | — | — |
| Missouri Habano Toro | cigarclub.com | 71 USD | — | — |
| Florida Connecticut Toro | cigarclub.com | 71 USD | — | — |
| Ole Miss Habano Toro | cigarclub.com | 71 USD | — | — |
| La Palina - Reserva 765 Exclusive | cigarclub.com | 70 USD | — | — |
| La Palina - Reserva 643 Exclusive | cigarclub.com | 70 USD | — | — |
| Purito Box | cigarclub.com | 69 USD | 49 USD | — |
| Redferno [Quad Flame Table Lighter] | cigarclub.com | 60 USD | — | — |
| 2025 CigarClub Customs Vol 6: Gemini | cigarclub.com | 59.99 USD | 45 USD | — |
| 2024 CigarClub Customs Vol 3: Fortis | cigarclub.com | 59.99 USD | — | — |
| 2025 CigarClub Customs Vol 5: Coven | cigarclub.com | 59.99 USD | 45 USD | — |
| 2024 CigarClub Customs Vol 1: Elysium | cigarclub.com | 59.99 USD | 0 USD | — |