| Rancho Cucamonga Quakes Foam Finger | quakes.milbstore.com | 3 USD | 8 USD | −62.5% |
| Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders COPA Vejigantes Mask | railriders.milbstore.com | 3.99 USD | 7.99 USD | −50.1% |
| Syracuse Mets Foam Baseball Hat | syracusemets.milbstore.com | 6 USD | 9.99 USD | −39.9% |
| EXHUMED "Limb from Limb" Foam Chainsaw Waver | darker-corners.myshopify.com | 16.66 USD | 19.99 USD | −16.7% |
| Brewers Sunday Seat Cushion | timberrattlers.milbstore.com | 20 USD | — | — |
| Syracuse Mets Orange Foam Cowboy Hat | syracusemets.milbstore.com | 19.99 USD | — | — |
| Eugene Emeralds Foam Cowboy Hat | emeralds.milbstore.com | 18 USD | — | — |
| Foam Hot Dog Hat | whitecaps.milbstore.com | 16.99 USD | — | — |
| Foam Duck hat | rubberducks.milbstore.com | 15 USD | — | — |
| Wisconsin Flying Brats Foam Hot Dog Hat | timberrattlers.milbstore.com | 15.0 USD | — | — |
| Gwinnett Stripers FoamWorx Foam Hot Dog Hat | gostripers.milbstore.com | 15 USD | — | — |
| Greenville Drive Foamworx Yellow Hot Dog Hat | drive.milbstore.com | 15 USD | — | — |
| Brooklyn Cyclones Foam Hot Dog Hat | cyclones.milbstore.com | 15 USD | — | — |
| Eugene Emeralds FoamWorx Foam Hot Dog Hat | emeralds.milbstore.com | 15 USD | — | — |
| Tulsa Drillers Foam Hot Dog Hat | drillers.milbstore.com | 14.99 USD | — | — |
| OKC Comets Hot Dog Foam Hat | okccomets.milbstore.com | 14.99 USD | — | — |
| Jacksonville Jumbo Shrimp Foamworx Foam Hot Dog Hat | jaxshrimp.milbstore.com | 14 USD | — | — |
| St. Paul Saints Wiener Hats | saints.milbstore.com | 14 USD | — | — |
| Edmonton Oilers Navy Alternate Script Foam Finger | icedistrictauthentics.com | 13.99 CAD | — | — |
| Frederick Keys Foam Claw | keys.milbstore.com | 13 USD | — | — |
| Edmonton Oil Kings Blue Alternate Logo Foam Finger | icedistrictauthentics.com | 12.99 CAD | — | — |
| Gwinnett Stripers Foam Fish Hat | gostripers.milbstore.com | 12 USD | 12 USD | — |
| Lehigh Valley IronPigs Foam Hot Dog Hat | ironpigs.milbstore.com | 12 USD | — | — |
| Frederick Keys Seat Cushions | keys.milbstore.com | 12 USD | — | — |
| Claw Foam Finger | tommieslockerroom.com | 12 USD | — | — |
| Eugene Emeralds FoamWorx Exploding Whales Dynamite Tail | emeralds.milbstore.com | 12 USD | — | — |
| Tulsa Drillers Foam Baseball Mitt | drillers.milbstore.com | 9.99 USD | — | — |
| Frederick Keys Foam Sword | keys.milbstore.com | 9 USD | — | — |
| Lake Elsinore Storm Foam Finger | storm.milbstore.com | 9 USD | — | — |
| Lake Elsinore Storm Thunder Paw | storm.milbstore.com | 9 USD | — | — |
| OKC Comets Pink Foam Finger | okccomets.milbstore.com | 8 USD | — | — |
| Eugene Emeralds FoamWorx Green Foam Finger | emeralds.milbstore.com | 8 USD | — | — |
| Wichita Wind Surge 18in Foam Finger | windsurge.milbstore.com | 8 USD | — | — |
| Bradenton Marauders Foam Glove | marauders.milbstore.com | 8 USD | — | — |
| Gwinnett Stripers Foam Fishing Rod | gostripers.milbstore.com | 8 USD | 8 USD | — |
| FW Mason Jar Foam Mit | fireflies.milbstore.com | 8 USD | — | — |
| Syracuse Mets Foam Orange Baseball Bat Hat | syracusemets.milbstore.com | 7.99 USD | — | — |
| Greenville Drive Rico USA Foam Finger | drive.milbstore.com | 7 USD | — | — |
| Frederick Keys Foam Finger | keys.milbstore.com | 7 USD | — | — |
| Aberdeen IronBirds FOAM Finger | ironbirds.shopbaseballcollective.com | 7 USD | — | — |