| CJ Stroud 2023 Topps Now X Beck Black Foil Autograph /99 (09/99) PSA 10 | sweets-and-geeks.myshopify.com | 850 USD | — | — |
| CJ Stroud 2023 Topps Now X Beck Black Foil Autograph /99 (09/99) PSA 10 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 850 USD | — | — |
| Daniel Jones 2019 Panini Absolute Rookie Premiere Materials Autograph /99 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 175 USD | — | — |
| Troy Aikman 2024 Topps Chrome Black Refractor Autograph /20 (20/20) | sweetsandgeeks.com | 160 USD | — | — |
| Troy Aikman 2024 Topps Chrome Black Refractor Autograph /20 (20/20) | sweets-and-geeks.myshopify.com | 160 USD | — | — |
| Nick Chubb 2018 Panini Donruss Optic Rated Rookie Holo Autograph /99 (91/99) Beckett 9.5 Autograph 10 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 150 USD | — | — |
| Nick Chubb 2018 Panini Donruss Optic Rated Rookie Holo Autograph /99 (91/99) Beckett 9.5 Autograph 10 | sweets-and-geeks.myshopify.com | 150 USD | — | — |
| Bo Nix 2023 Leaf Flash Rookie Autograph Flash of Brilliance Zebra /4 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 125 USD | — | — |
| Andy Dalton 2015 Gold Panini Prizm Auto /10 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 120 USD | — | — |
| Baker Mayfield 2019 Panini Donruss Optic Gold /10 PSA 9 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 110 USD | — | — |
| Carnell Tate 2024 Bowman University's Best Autograph | sweetsandgeeks.com | 75 USD | — | — |
| Randy Moss 1998 Topps Chrome Rookie Draft Picks | sweetsandgeeks.com | 75 USD | — | — |
| Ja'marr Chase 2021 Panini Select Black Gold Die Cut Prizm Rookie PSA 10 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 75 USD | — | — |
| Carnell Tate 2024 Bowman University's Best Autograph | sweets-and-geeks.myshopify.com | 75 USD | — | — |
| Jerry Rice 1986 Topps Rookie #161 EX | sweetsandgeeks.com | 65 USD | — | — |
| Drew Allar 2024 Wild Card Allumination Dino-Might Auto /2 | sweets-and-geeks.myshopify.com | 60 USD | — | — |
| Drew Allar 2024 Wild Card Allumination Dino-Might Auto /2 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 60 USD | — | — |
| Josh Allen 2021 Panini Prestige Heroes Green /199 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 60 USD | — | — |
| Quinshon Judkins 2025 Panini Mosaic Rookie PSA 10 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 60 USD | — | — |
| CeeDee Lamb 2020 Panini Certified New Generation Rookie Patch /99 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 60 USD | — | — |
| Brian Thomas Jr 2024 Panini Prizm Pink Rookie Auto | sweetsandgeeks.com | 60 USD | — | — |
| Dan Marino 1984 Topps #123 Rookie AFC Pro Bowl Excellent | sweetsandgeeks.com | 50 USD | — | — |
| Drew Allar 2023 Topps Bowman Chrome U Refractor Auto /499 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 50 USD | — | — |
| Chris Olave 2022 Panini Zenith Rookie Red Wave PSA 10 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 50 USD | — | — |
| Myles Garrett 2019 Panini Donruss Gold Die Cut /25 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 50 USD | — | — |
| Ray Lewis 2025 Panini Prizm Red Sparkle | sweetsandgeeks.com | 50 USD | — | — |
| Drew Allar 2023 Topps Bowman Chrome U Refractor Auto /499 | sweets-and-geeks.myshopify.com | 50 USD | — | — |
| Dan Marino 1996 Collectors Edge 24K Holofoil /250 EX | sweetsandgeeks.com | 45 USD | — | — |
| Myles Garrett 2017 Panini Donruss Optic Rookie PSA 9 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 45 USD | — | — |
| Nick Chubb 2022 Panini Select Sensations Gold /10 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 40 USD | — | — |
| Parris Cambell 2019 Panini Immaculate Collection Collegiate RPA /99 3 Color Patch | sweetsandgeeks.com | 40 USD | — | — |
| Jaxon Smith-Njigba 2023 Panini Mosaic Draft Picks Rookie Blue Mosaic /75 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 40 USD | — | — |
| CJ Stroud 2024 Topps Chrome Composite Rookie Aqua Lava /175 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 40 USD | — | — |
| Drew Allar 2024 Wild Card 7 Card Stud Rookie Auto /4 PSA 8 | sweets-and-geeks.myshopify.com | 40 USD | — | — |
| Drew Allar 2024 Wild Card 7 Card Stud Rookie Auto /4 PSA 8 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 40 USD | — | — |
| Jerry Jeudy 2020 Leaf Trinity Autograph with "Go Broncos" Inscription (Graded SGC 9.5-10) | sweetsandgeeks.com | 35 USD | — | — |
| John Elway 1984 Topps Rookie #63 EX | sweetsandgeeks.com | 35 USD | — | — |
| Josh Allen 2021 Panini Chronicles Revolution /100 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 35 USD | — | — |
| Lamar "Bo" Jackson 2025 Panini Prizm Black Blue Ice Prizm /125 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 35 USD | — | — |
| Bucky Irving Panini Contenders 2024 Rookie Auto 022/100 | sweetsandgeeks.com | 35.0 USD | — | — |