| Camp Punch | quietneighbor.help | 1 USD | 8 USD | −87.5% |
| Nessie Hoodie | quietneighbor.help | 433 USD | — | — |
| Frightday Dad Hat | quietneighbor.help | 241 USD | — | — |
| Only a Podcast Crew | quietneighbor.help | 231 USD | — | — |
| Roswell Daily Record's Big Day/The Roswell Incident Tape Bundle | quietneighbor.help | 193 USD | — | — |
| Too Too Too Too Ghoul for School Shirt | quietneighbor.help | 193 USD | — | — |
| Too Ghoul for School (Black & White) | quietneighbor.help | 193 USD | — | — |
| Only a Podcast Baseball Shirt | quietneighbor.help | 183 USD | — | — |
| Nessie Bag | quietneighbor.help | 126 USD | — | — |
| King of Nye Enamel Pin | quietneighbor.help | 97 USD | — | — |
| Boo Crew Enamel Pin (Glow-in-the-Dark) | quietneighbor.help | 97 USD | — | — |
| High Hopes Enamel Pin | quietneighbor.help | 97 USD | — | — |
| KCC Abduction Tee (Glow-in-the-Dark) | quietneighbor.help | 97 USD | — | — |
| KCC Academy Enamel Pin | quietneighbor.help | 97 USD | — | — |
| Suppressive Person Enamel Pin | quietneighbor.help | 97 USD | — | — |
| Too Ghoul For School Enamel Pin | quietneighbor.help | 97 USD | — | — |
| Camp Frightday IV Counselor Package | quietneighbor.help | 68 USD | — | — |
| "The Roswell Incident: A Captain Kelly's Cryptids & Conspiracies Special Presentation" Cassette | quietneighbor.help | 65 USD | — | — |
| Hairwolf Shirt | quietneighbor.help | 65 USD | — | — |
| Murder House Patch | quietneighbor.help | 65 USD | — | — |
| Too Ghoul for School (Reflective Edition) | quietneighbor.help | 65 USD | — | — |
| "String Board" Starter Kit | quietneighbor.help | 65 USD | — | — |
| Camp Frightday III Embroidered Crew | quietneighbor.help | 40 USD | — | — |
| Fresno Nightcrawler Shirt | quietneighbor.help | 35 USD | — | — |
| Ghoul Shirt | quietneighbor.help | 32 USD | — | — |
| The Assassination of RFK Shirt | quietneighbor.help | 32 USD | — | — |
| Camp Frightday IV Cabin Shirt | quietneighbor.help | 31 USD | — | — |
| Moon June '23 Shirt | quietneighbor.help | 29 USD | — | — |
| Camp Frightday III Pom Beanie | quietneighbor.help | 27 USD | — | — |
| Camp Frightday Baseball Shirt | quietneighbor.help | 23 USD | — | — |
| Nessie Shirt | quietneighbor.help | 20 USD | — | — |
| Gates of Hell: Chipotle Hot Sauce | quietneighbor.help | 13 USD | — | — |
| Camp Frightday IV Poster | quietneighbor.help | 13 USD | — | — |
| Femur Pen | quietneighbor.help | 3 USD | 3 USD | — |