| The Angell Box | store.hplhs.org | 1000 USD | — | — |
| Dark Adventure Radio Theatre® - Masks of Nyarlathotep Deluxe Edition | store.hplhs.org | 249 USD | — | — |
| The Spark Devil | store.hplhs.org | 174.99 USD | — | — |
| The Golden Mirror | store.hplhs.org | 159 USD | — | — |
| The Spark Devil - International Edition | store.hplhs.org | 149.99 USD | — | — |
| Masks of Nyarlathotep - Gamer Prop Set | store.hplhs.org | 139 USD | — | — |
| Innsmouth Combo | store.hplhs.org | 123.95 USD | — | — |
| Call of Cthulhu Classic Gamer Prop Set | store.hplhs.org | 119 USD | — | — |
| The Eye of Light and Darkness | store.hplhs.org | 95 USD | — | — |
| Cthulhu Tupilak Replica | store.hplhs.org | 95 USD | — | — |
| Dark Adventure Radio Theatre® - Collector Sets | store.hplhs.org | 90 USD | — | — |
| The Cyclopean Holiday Combo | store.hplhs.org | 89 USD | — | — |
| Tooth of Dagon - Innsmouth Scrimshaw Replica | store.hplhs.org | 75 USD | — | — |
| Miskatonic Varsity Hoodie | store.hplhs.org | 75 USD | — | — |
| Mountains of Madness Combo | store.hplhs.org | 72 USD | — | — |
| Eternity at Sea | store.hplhs.org | 69.99 USD | — | — |
| Miskatonic University Combo | store.hplhs.org | 64.95 USD | — | — |
| Miskatonic Antarctic Expedition Hoodie | store.hplhs.org | 64.95 USD | — | — |
| Call of Cthulhu Combo | store.hplhs.org | 64.95 USD | — | — |
| HPLHS Font and Prop Combo | store.hplhs.org | 60 USD | — | — |
| An Unbearably Scary Solstice Combo | store.hplhs.org | 59.95 USD | — | — |
| El Profundo Mayan Replica | store.hplhs.org | 55 USD | 0 USD | — |
| Esoteric Order of Dagon Hoodie | store.hplhs.org | 53.95 USD | — | — |
| Miskatonic Collegiate Hoodie | store.hplhs.org | 53.95 USD | — | — |
| Miskatonic Tibetan Hoodie | store.hplhs.org | 50 USD | — | — |
| Deep One Summoning Stones | store.hplhs.org | 50 USD | — | — |
| The Literature of Lovecraft Audiobook | store.hplhs.org | 50 USD | — | — |
| HPLHS Fonts (Single User Personal License) | store.hplhs.org | 50 USD | — | — |
| Arkham Investigator's Wallet Prop Set | store.hplhs.org | 49.95 USD | — | — |
| John Dee Elder Sign | store.hplhs.org | 49.71 USD | — | — |
| Gamer Prop Add-On | store.hplhs.org | 45 USD | — | — |
| Audio Props: The Two-Headed Serpent | store.hplhs.org | 39.95 USD | — | — |
| Audio Props: The Order of the Stone | store.hplhs.org | 39.95 USD | — | — |
| Dark Adventure Radio Theatre® - Masks of Nyarlathotep | store.hplhs.org | 34.95 USD | — | — |
| Arkham Sanitarium Patient Shirt | store.hplhs.org | 31.95 USD | — | — |
| The Collaboration Tales of H.P. Lovecraft Audiobook | store.hplhs.org | 30 USD | — | — |
| Call of Cthulhu Classic Newspaper | store.hplhs.org | 27.5 USD | — | — |
| Audio Props: God's Teeth | store.hplhs.org | 27 USD | — | — |
| Knowledge is Power T-shirt | store.hplhs.org | 26.95 USD | — | — |
| Call of Cthulhu T-shirt | store.hplhs.org | 26.95 USD | — | — |