| Leo De Vries Autographed Padres Batting Helmet | shoplegends.com | 125 USD | 210 USD | −40.5% |
| Roman Anthony Autographed Boston Red Sox Logo Baseball | shoplegends.com | 250 USD | 315 USD | −20.6% |
| Cam Coleman Autographed Orange Custom Jersey | shoplegends.com | 125 USD | 150 USD | −16.7% |
| Konnor Griffin Autographed MLB Debut Game Ticket | shoplegends.com | 695 USD | 750 USD | −7.3% |
| Framed Shohei Ohtani Autographed White Replica Angels Jersey | shoplegends.com | 323525 USD | — | — |
| Los Angeles Dodgers 2025 Team Signed Replica Jersey LE /50 | shoplegends.com | 146988 USD | — | — |
| Los Angeles Dodgers 2025 World Series Team Autographed Celebration 16x20 LE /50 | shoplegends.com | 107842 USD | — | — |
| Derek Jeter Autographed Louisville Slugger Game Model Bat with "HOF 2020" Inscription | shoplegends.com | 48529 USD | — | — |
| Mike Trout Autographed "Millville Meteor" Zoom Trout 3 Turf 2017 Trout Alt Turf Size 11.5 - Player's Closet Project | shoplegends.com | 43029 USD | — | — |
| Bryce Harper Autographed Authentic White Phillies Jersey | shoplegends.com | 41519 USD | — | — |
| 1997 All-Star Game Logo Baseball (Over 20+ National League Signatures) - Player's Closet Project | shoplegends.com | 32331 USD | — | — |
| 2003 All-Star Game Autographed Jack McDowell Legends Celebrity Event Model Bat - Player's Closet Project | shoplegends.com | 32331 USD | — | — |
| Paul Skenes Autographed Pirates Authentic White Jersey | shoplegends.com | 31598 USD | — | — |
| Tony Gwynn Autographed Final Season Game Line Up Card - Player's Closet Project | shoplegends.com | 30196 USD | — | — |
| Freddie Freeman Autographed White LA Dodgers Authentic Jersey with 24 & 25 WS Logo Patches | shoplegends.com | 29333 USD | — | — |
| 1967 Boston Red Sox - Various Players - Player's Closet Project | shoplegends.com | 28039 USD | — | — |
| Drake Maye Autographed UNC Authentic Football Helmet | shoplegends.com | 23834 USD | — | — |
| Hideo Nomo Autographed Los Angeles Dodgers Authentic Jersey - Player's Closet Project | shoplegends.com | 21461 USD | — | — |
| Vladimir Guerrero Sr, Torii Hunter, Garret Anderson Triple Autographed 2024 Topps Series 2 Trading Card - Limited Edition 4/5 | shoplegends.com | 21461 USD | — | — |
| Lou Holtz Autographed 88 Natl Champs Notre Dame Authentic Full-Size Helmet | shoplegends.com | 21461 USD | — | — |
| Tony Gwynn Autographed San Diego Padres Hat - Player's Closet Project | shoplegends.com | 21461 USD | — | — |
| Madonna Autographed Framed Photo - Player's Closet Project | shoplegends.com | 19390 USD | — | — |
| Cal Raleigh Autographed Blonde Game Model Victus Bat | shoplegends.com | 18873 USD | — | — |
| Mike Piazza Autographed Mets Mitchell & Ness Pinstripe Authentic Jersey | shoplegends.com | 18657 USD | — | — |
| Kike Hernandez & Freddie Freeman Dual Autographed 16x20 Photo - Celebration | shoplegends.com | 18333 USD | — | — |
| Elijah Sarratt and Omar Cooper Jr. Dual Autographed "Hoo-Hoo-Hoo & Hoosiers!" Indiana Authentic Football Helmet | shoplegends.com | 18333 USD | — | — |
| Munetaka Murakami Chicago White Sox Autographed Baseball | shoplegends.com | 18333 USD | — | — |
| Bryce Harper Autographed Baseball | shoplegends.com | 18118 USD | — | — |
| Justin Jefferson Autographed Vikings Authentic Full-Size Helmet | shoplegends.com | 18118 USD | — | — |
| 2008 ASG NL Team Signed Baseball - Player's Closet Project | shoplegends.com | 17255 USD | — | — |
| Tommy Lasorda Autographed St. Patrick Day Los Angeles Dodgers Hat - Player's Closet Project | shoplegends.com | 17147 USD | — | — |
| Cal Ripken Jr. Autographed Game Model Bat | shoplegends.com | 17039 USD | — | — |
| Pete Alonso Autographed Dove Tail Axe Game Model Bat | shoplegends.com | 17039 USD | — | — |
| Konnor Griffin Autographed "MLB Debut 4/3/26" Pittsburgh Pirates White Authentic Jersey (PRESALE) | shoplegends.com | 16716 USD | — | — |
| Jared Goff Autographed Detroit Lions Full-Size Replica Football Helmet | shoplegends.com | 16500 USD | — | — |
| Jose Altuve Autographed White Authentic Astros Jersey | shoplegends.com | 16285 USD | — | — |
| Konnor Griffin Autographed "MLB Debut" MLB Debut Ticket Stub | shoplegends.com | 16176 USD | — | — |
| Bryson Stott Autographed Phillies White Nike Authentic Jersey | shoplegends.com | 15314 USD | — | — |
| Shohei Ohtani Autographed 2023 WBC Logo Baseball | shoplegends.com | 15000 USD | — | — |
| Konnor Griffin Autographed Pittsburgh Pirates Black Authentic Jersey (PRESALE) | shoplegends.com | 14990 USD | — | — |