| Mystery Malt Old School Malts 50 Year Old Coastal Edition Signatory | thewhiskybarrel.com | 567.36 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Laphroaig) Islay 31 Year Old 1990 Signatory Cask Strength | thewhiskybarrel.com | 427.95 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Laphroaig) Islay 28 Year Old 1992 Signatory Cask Strength | thewhiskybarrel.com | 366.95 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Macallan) 21 Year Old 2005 Signatory Symington’s Choice | thewhiskybarrel.com | 326.34 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Speyside M) 18 Year Old 2005 Signatory Cask Strength #41 | thewhiskybarrel.com | 238.95 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Speyside M) 18 Year Old 2007 Signatory Cask Strength | thewhiskybarrel.com | 237.95 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Highland Park) 21 Year Old 2005 Signatory Cask Strength | thewhiskybarrel.com | 223.05 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Highland Park) 20 Year Old 2005 Signatory Cask Strength | thewhiskybarrel.com | 223.05 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Orkney) 22 Year Old 2003 Infrequent Flyers | thewhiskybarrel.com | 214.78 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt Islay 18 Year Old 2007 Infrequent Flyers | thewhiskybarrel.com | 174.84 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt Speyside 15 Year Old 2009 Single Malts of Scotland | thewhiskybarrel.com | 150.05 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Macallan) 16 Year Old 2009 Signatory Un-Chillfiltered for TWB | thewhiskybarrel.com | 132.15 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Macallan) 16 Year Old 2009 Signatory Un-Chillfiltered for TWB | thewhiskybarrel.com | 132.15 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Macallan) 17 Year Old 2008 Signatory Exceptional Cask Edition #16 | thewhiskybarrel.com | 125.52 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Macallan) 18 Year Old 2008 Signatory Exceptional Cask Edition #17 | thewhiskybarrel.com | 125.52 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Speyside M) 16 Year Old 2009 Signatory Un-Chillfiltered for TWB | thewhiskybarrel.com | 122.95 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Orkney) 21 Year Old 2004 Unicorn for TWB | thewhiskybarrel.com | 122.58 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Macallan) 16 Year Old 2009 Signatory Exceptional Cask Edition #15 | thewhiskybarrel.com | 118.39 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Secret Speyside M) 16 Year Old 2009 Signatory Exceptional Cask Edition #13 | thewhiskybarrel.com | 117 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Highland Park) 16 Year Old 2010 Unicorn for TWB | thewhiskybarrel.com | 108.8 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Orkney HP) 16 Year Old 2009 Unicorn for TWB | thewhiskybarrel.com | 108.8 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Orkney) 11 Year Old 2013 Lady of the Glen | thewhiskybarrel.com | 100.95 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Macallan) 16 Year Old 2009 Signatory Un-Chillfiltered for TWB | thewhiskybarrel.com | 97.95 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Macallan) 14 Year Old 2011 Signatory Small Batch #20 | thewhiskybarrel.com | 88.08 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Glenlivet) 16 Year Old Signatory Exceptional Cask Edition #8 | thewhiskybarrel.com | 81.95 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Highland Park) 15 Year Old 2011 Signatory 100-Proof Edition #83 | thewhiskybarrel.com | 75.68 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Orkney HP) 14 Year Old 2011 Signatory 100-Proof Edition #71 | thewhiskybarrel.com | 75.68 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Glenkinchie) 13 Year Old Single Malts of Scotland | thewhiskybarrel.com | 71.95 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt Whitlaw (Highland Park) 8 Year Old 2018 Signatory Un-Chillfiltered | thewhiskybarrel.com | 67.42 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Speyside M) 15 Year Old 2009 Signatory Small Batch #19 | thewhiskybarrel.com | 63.95 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Speyside M) 14 Year Old 2010 Signatory Small Batch #16 | thewhiskybarrel.com | 61.95 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Speyside M) 15 Year Old 2009 Signatory Small Batch #18 | thewhiskybarrel.com | 61.95 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Orkney HP) 14 Year Old 2011 Signatory 100-Proof Edition #58 | thewhiskybarrel.com | 54.95 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Orkney HP) 14 Year Old 2011 Signatory 100-Proof Edition #59 | thewhiskybarrel.com | 54.95 GBP | — | — |
| Mystery Malt (Highland Park) 14 Year Old 2010 Signatory 100-Proof Edition #38 | thewhiskybarrel.com | 53.95 GBP | — | — |