| Always Proud Identity Flag Sticker | mythical.com | 2.5 USD | 4.99 USD | −49.9% |
| Wheel of Mythicality Pin | mythical.com | 11.99 USD | 14.99 USD | −20% |
| GMM Neon Sign Tee | mythical.com | 26.99 USD | 29.99 USD | −10% |
| Summer of Society Bundle | mythical.com | 3337 USD | — | — |
| GMM Colorblock Set (Olive) | mythical.com | 3336 USD | — | — |
| GMM Colorblock Set (Brown) | mythical.com | 3336 USD | — | — |
| Mythical Puzzle Bundle | mythical.com | 1766 USD | — | — |
| Last Meals Apron & Pin Bundle | mythical.com | 1745 USD | — | — |
| Tokyo Mt. Fuji Hoodie | mythical.com | 1668 USD | — | — |
| Last Meals Apron | mythical.com | 1540 USD | — | — |
| Mythical Stars Sweatshirt | mythical.com | 1412 USD | — | — |
| James and the Shame Nothing Left to Love Hoodie | mythical.com | 1412 USD | — | — |
| Mythical Outdoor Blanket | mythical.com | 1412 USD | — | — |
| James and the Shame Tentacle Text Hoodie | mythical.com | 1412 USD | — | — |
| Mythical Clue Game | mythical.com | 1001 USD | — | — |
| Good Mythical Mycology Long Sleeve Tee (Green) | mythical.com | 950 USD | — | — |
| Rhett & Link Sing Brooks & Dunn Vinyl in the Year 3000 12” Vinyl | mythical.com | 924 USD | — | — |
| Rhett & Link Covers Vinyl Bundle | mythical.com | 924 USD | — | — |
| Rhett & Link Comic Book Bundle | mythical.com | 924 USD | — | — |
| Blood Oath Comic Book #1: Rhett & Link vs the Global Lovemaking Crisis | mythical.com | 924 USD | — | — |
| Mythical Beast Blanket | mythical.com | 924 USD | — | — |
| Blood Oath Comic Book #3: Rhett & Link vs Gerard | mythical.com | 924 USD | — | — |
| Blood Oath Comic Book #2: Rhett & Link vs Barbara & Jade (and J.A.D.E.) | mythical.com | 924 USD | — | — |
| Rhett & Link's Epic Rap Battle 12” Vinyl | mythical.com | 924 USD | — | — |
| Rhett & Link Youtooz Collectible | mythical.com | 924 USD | — | — |
| Rhett & Link Vinyl Bundle | mythical.com | 924 USD | — | — |
| Mythical Society Blanket Hoodie | mythical.com | 924 USD | — | — |
| GMM Woven Blanket | mythical.com | 924 USD | — | — |
| James and the Shame Nothing Left to Love Tee | mythical.com | 898 USD | — | — |
| James and the Shame Leviathan Face Tee | mythical.com | 898 USD | — | — |
| James and the Shame Leviathan Guitar Tee | mythical.com | 898 USD | — | — |
| James and the Shame Stone Man Tee | mythical.com | 898 USD | — | — |
| Snackiverse Lunch Box & Thermos Set | mythical.com | 770 USD | — | — |
| Good Mythical Mycology Tee (Mauve) | mythical.com | 770 USD | — | — |
| The Lost Causes of Bleak Creek | mythical.com | 668 USD | — | — |
| My Hair Goes 12” Vinyl | mythical.com | 668 USD | — | — |
| Rhett & Link Sing Lionel 12” Vinyl | mythical.com | 668 USD | — | — |
| James and the Shame Human Overboard LP | mythical.com | 642 USD | — | — |
| James and the Shame Nothing Left to Love LP | mythical.com | 578 USD | — | — |
| James and the Shame Tentacle Text Bandana | mythical.com | 437 USD | — | — |