| The Construction Board Game Dig Into Some Fun! 2002 | throwbackbuys.com | 178.01 USD | — | — |
| Littlest Pet Shop Digital Pet Bird 2006 Hasbro NEW WORKS | throwbackbuys.com | 161.57 USD | — | — |
| Barbie The Island Princess Singing Doll Rosella Mattel | throwbackbuys.com | 142.1 USD | — | — |
| Rolie Polie Olie Plush's Zowie Spot Playhouse Disney | throwbackbuys.com | 95.91 USD | — | — |
| Ginger Snaps VHS 2001 Horror English | throwbackbuys.com | 95.63 USD | — | — |
| Crazy Frog The Annoying Thing Plush 2006 | throwbackbuys.com | 86.86 USD | — | — |
| Street Fighter 2 V VHS Manga Lot | throwbackbuys.com | 85 USD | — | — |
| Care Bear Cousin Treat Heart Pig Plush 20th Anniversary | throwbackbuys.com | 84.19 USD | — | — |
| Toopy and Binoo Plush White Cat Mouse Amuze | throwbackbuys.com | 68.95 USD | — | — |
| Bratz Winter Wonderland Cloe Doll 2001 | throwbackbuys.com | 65.14 USD | — | — |
| Bratz Ooh La La Makeup Lip Gloss Kit 2005 | throwbackbuys.com | 64.81 USD | — | — |
| Bratz Boyz Dolls Koby Cameron MGA | throwbackbuys.com | 53.86 USD | — | — |
| Jaws 1 2 and 3 VHS Tapes Movies | throwbackbuys.com | 48.11 USD | — | — |
| Nosy Bear 1987 Plush Playskool Popcorn Neon Pink | throwbackbuys.com | 45.03 USD | — | — |
| Barbie Kelly Dolls Wizard of OZ Munchkins 2000 | throwbackbuys.com | 43.43 USD | — | — |
| Over The Hedge Hammy Squirrel Plush 2006 | throwbackbuys.com | 43.08 USD | — | — |
| Caillou Airplane with Rotating Propellers 2003 | throwbackbuys.com | 42.63 USD | — | — |
| Lil Bratz Yasmin Mini Doll 2002 MGA | throwbackbuys.com | 32.41 USD | — | — |
| Polly Pocket Simply Charming Kit 2004 Mattel | throwbackbuys.com | 32.31 USD | — | — |
| Winx Club Handle Bag Container Fairies Stella Layla Flora Teena Bloom Musa | throwbackbuys.com | 31.97 USD | — | — |
| McDonald's Plush Keychains Fries Big Mac Filet-O-Fish 2002 | throwbackbuys.com | 31.88 USD | — | — |
| Bratz Kidz Ice Champion Cloe Doll | throwbackbuys.com | 27.5 USD | — | — |
| Winx Club The Secret of Alfea Comic Book Magazine 2005 | throwbackbuys.com | 27 USD | — | — |
| Pixel Chix Road Trippin' Blue Car Interactive Keychain 2005 WORKS Missing Hood | throwbackbuys.com | 26.92 USD | — | — |
| Caillou and Friends Figure Set Leo Clementine Bike 2002 PBS | throwbackbuys.com | 26.73 USD | — | — |
| Micro Pets Cat Tomy 2002 Chumsley WORKS | throwbackbuys.com | 26.73 USD | — | — |
| Happy Feet Mumble Plush Penguin Rubber Nose | throwbackbuys.com | 26.73 USD | — | — |
| What Would Lizzie Do? Lizzie McGuire Board Game 2003 | throwbackbuys.com | 25.33 USD | — | — |
| Dora the Explorer View Master Dora's World Adventure Nickelodeon 2006 | throwbackbuys.com | 25 USD | — | — |
| Beanie Babies Collector Cards 1st Edition Series 2 Canadian Version Trading Cards 1998 | throwbackbuys.com | 24 USD | — | — |
| Lisa Frank Colour and Doodle Picture Frame Kit | throwbackbuys.com | 23.16 USD | — | — |
| In The Night Garden Figures 2006 Makka Pakka Igglepiggle | throwbackbuys.com | 21.71 USD | — | — |
| Bear in the Big Blue House Bear's Super Shape Search Sticker Book 2001 | throwbackbuys.com | 21.54 USD | — | — |
| Barbie Glamour Jewelry Kit 1995 | throwbackbuys.com | 21.54 USD | — | — |
| Webkinz Trading Card Album Binder Sealed with CODE | throwbackbuys.com | 21.05 USD | — | — |
| Barbie Calling All Friends! Photo Phone Book 2000 | throwbackbuys.com | 21.05 USD | — | — |
| lip Rageous Lip Balm Watermelon 90's Y2K Clipstick | throwbackbuys.com | 19.39 USD | — | — |
| Y2K Glitter Pink Flower Clip Board with Fluffy Pen | throwbackbuys.com | 17.23 USD | — | — |
| Blue's Clues Musical Light Up Boombox 2000 Nickelodeon | throwbackbuys.com | 15.8 USD | — | — |
| Barbie Plush Photo Cube 2002 | throwbackbuys.com | 15.44 USD | — | — |