| 75th Anniversary Banner (4x4) | shop.pony.org | 50 USD | — | — |
| 75th Anniversary Banner (4x4) (Director Only) | shop.pony.org | 45 USD | — | — |
| 75th Anniversary Banner's (3x3) | shop.pony.org | 40 USD | — | — |
| 75th Anniversary Banner's (3x3) (Director Only) | shop.pony.org | 35 USD | — | — |
| PONY Portfolio | shop.pony.org | 35 USD | — | — |
| PONY "Golf Style" Umbrella | shop.pony.org | 30 USD | — | — |
| PONY Canvas Briefcase | shop.pony.org | 30 USD | — | — |
| PONY Baseball and Softball Alumni Membership / Scholarship Donation | shop.pony.org | 25 USD | — | — |
| PONY Watch | shop.pony.org | 25 USD | — | — |
| 75th Anniversary T-Shirt | shop.pony.org | 20 USD | — | — |
| PONY Mini Portfolio | shop.pony.org | 13 USD | — | — |
| PONY Coffee Mugs | shop.pony.org | 10 USD | — | — |
| DICK'S Sporting Goods Baseball/Softball Scorebook | shop.pony.org | 7 USD | — | — |
| Official Batting Order - Lineup Cards | shop.pony.org | 6 USD | — | — |
| Champions League Combo Pack | shop.pony.org | 6 USD | — | — |
| Director Promo Item - Champions League Combo Pack | shop.pony.org | 6 USD | — | — |
| Director Promo Item - Official Batting Order - Lineup Cards | shop.pony.org | 6 USD | — | — |
| PONY 65th Anniversary Patch | shop.pony.org | 5 USD | — | — |
| Lew Hays Field Numbered Print | shop.pony.org | 5 USD | — | — |
| 2026 PONY Girls Softball Rulebook | shop.pony.org | 4 USD | — | — |
| Director Promo Item - 2026 PONY Girls Softball Rulebook | shop.pony.org | 4 USD | — | — |
| PONY State Champion Medallion w/attached Non-Dated Ribbon | shop.pony.org | 3.75 USD | — | — |
| I "Heart" PONY Logo Pin | shop.pony.org | 3 USD | — | — |
| Director Promo Order - I "Heart" PONY Logo Pin | shop.pony.org | 3 USD | — | — |
| Director Promo Item - 2026 PONY Baseball Rulebook | shop.pony.org | 3 USD | — | — |
| 2026 PONY Baseball Rulebook | shop.pony.org | 3 USD | — | — |
| PONY World Series Medallion w/attached Ribbon | shop.pony.org | 2.85 USD | — | — |
| PONY Zone Medallion w/attached Ribbon | shop.pony.org | 2.5 USD | — | — |
| Director Promo Item - PONY Tournament Team Emblem / Patch | shop.pony.org | 2 USD | — | — |
| PONY Tournament Team Emblems / Patch | shop.pony.org | 2 USD | — | — |
| PONY Super-Region Medallion w/attached Ribbon | shop.pony.org | 1.9 USD | — | — |
| PONY Region Medallion w/attached Ribbon | shop.pony.org | 1.65 USD | — | — |
| PONY Section Medallion w/attached Ribbon | shop.pony.org | 1.5 USD | — | — |
| PONY District Medallion w/attached Ribbon | shop.pony.org | 1.4 USD | — | — |
| Director Promo Order - PONY Pen | shop.pony.org | 1 USD | — | — |
| 75th Anniversary Trading Pins | shop.pony.org | 1 USD | — | — |
| PONY Pen | shop.pony.org | 1 USD | — | — |
| Medallion Ribbon | shop.pony.org | 0.75 USD | — | — |
| Director Promo Order - PONY Pencil | shop.pony.org | 0.25 USD | — | — |
| PONY Pencil | shop.pony.org | 0.25 USD | — | — |