| Tris Speaker Signed Slabbed Government Postcard 1948 PSA DNA 10 GEM MINT HOF | sportscards.com | 56941 USD | — | — |
| Stephen Curry Signed GS Warriors Nike Swingman Blue Jersey Upper Deck UDA COA | sportscards.com | 51985 USD | — | — |
| Connor McDavid Signed Autographed Erie Otters OHL Game Puck Upper Deck UDA COA | sportscards.com | 25054 USD | — | — |
| Gary Sheffield Signed Game Used Sam Bat Black Bat JSA COA Braves B | sportscards.com | 19930 USD | — | — |
| Gary Sheffield Signed Game Used Sam Bat Natural Bat JSA COA Braves A | sportscards.com | 19930 USD | — | — |
| Gary Sheffield Signed Game Used Louisville Slugger Black Bat JSA COA Dodgers A | sportscards.com | 18506 USD | — | — |
| (1) 2023-24 Panini Prizm Deca NBA Basketball Factory Sealed (10) Box Hobby Case | shopatluckys.com | 18499.99 USD | 0 USD | — |
| Paul Skenes Signed MLB Debut Ticket 5/11/2024 w/ Inscription PSA 10 Auto Pirates | sportscards.com | 18195 USD | — | — |
| Gary Sheffield Signed Game Used Rawlings Black Bat JSA COA Dodgers B | sportscards.com | 17083 USD | — | — |
| Tom Selleck Signed Autographed Detroit Tigers Logo Baseball Official Pix JSA COA | sportscards.com | 15374 USD | — | — |
| Trey Hendrickson Signed Ravens Authentic FS Full Size Helmet w/ Insc JSA W COA | sportscards.com | 14236 USD | — | — |
| Tom Selleck Signed Autographed ROMLB Baseball Official Pix + JSA COA Actor | sportscards.com | 14236 USD | — | — |
| Paul Skenes Signed MLB Debut Ticket 5/11/2024 w/ Inscription PSA Authentic Auto | sportscards.com | 12997 USD | — | — |
| Pedro Martinez Signed Mitchell & Ness Authentic Red Sox Jersey 7x Insc JSA W COA | sportscards.com | 11697 USD | — | — |
| Tom Selleck Signed Autographed Detroit Tigers Logo Baseball Official Pix JSA COA | sportscards.com | 11560 USD | — | — |
| Chipper Jones Signed Atlanta Braves Russell Authentic Jersey w 99 NL MVP JSA COA | sportscards.com | 11388 USD | — | — |
| Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Signed MLB Debut & First Hit Full Ticket 2 Ins PSA 10 Auto | sportscards.com | 10397 USD | — | — |
| Allen Iverson Signed Philadelphia 76ers 96-97 Mitchell & Ness M&N Jersey UDA COA | sportscards.com | 10397 USD | — | — |
| Miguel Cabrera Signed 3000th Hit Ticket 4/23/2022 w/ Inscription PSA 9 + Auto 10 | sportscards.com | 9748 USD | — | — |
| Ray Knight Signed 1986 World Series Game 2 Ticket w/ 1986 WS MVP Ins PSA 10 Auto | sportscards.com | 9748 USD | — | — |
| Giannis Antetokounmpo Signed Milwaukee Bucks Nike Jersey Beckett Witness BAS COA | sportscards.com | 9680 USD | — | — |
| Brett Favre Signed Green Bay Packers Mitchell & Ness Jersey Upper Deck UDA COA | sportscards.com | 9423 USD | — | — |
| Bo Jackson Signed Autographed Kansas City Royals Logo Baseball JSA Witness COA | sportscards.com | 9111 USD | — | — |
| Bo Jackson Signed Autographed 1989 All Star Game Baseball JSA Witness COA Royals | sportscards.com | 9111 USD | — | — |
| Zack Wheeler Signed Auto MLB Debut Ticket 6/18/2013 w/ Insc PSA 9 MINT 10 Auto | sportscards.com | 9098 USD | — | — |
| Alexander Ovechkin Signed Washington Capitals Fanatics Authentic Jersey JSA COA | sportscards.com | 9098 USD | — | — |
| Trey Hendrickson Signed Ravens Alt #1 FS Full Size Helmet JSA Witness COA | sportscards.com | 8542 USD | — | — |
| Trey Hendrickson Signed Ravens Alt #2 FS Full Size Helmet JSA Witness COA | sportscards.com | 8542 USD | — | — |
| Pete Rose Signed Autographed Genuine Hit King Black w/ Hit King FITERMAN COA | sportscards.com | 8542 USD | — | — |
| Trey Hendrickson Signed Ravens Speed FS Full Size Helmet JSA Witness COA | sportscards.com | 7972 USD | — | — |
| Connor Hellebuyck Signed Jets Logo Puck Secretary of Defense Insc. Fanatics COA | sportscards.com | 7972 USD | — | — |
| Cody Bellinger Signed Autographed New York Yankees Custom Jersey JSA COA | sportscards.com | 7972 USD | — | — |
| Jack Hughes Signed New Jersey Devils Logo Puck w/ Raise Hell Insc. Fanatics COA | sportscards.com | 7972 USD | — | — |
| Bo Jackson Signed Autographed ROMLB Baseball JSA Witness COA Kansas City Royals | sportscards.com | 7687 USD | — | — |
| Igor Shesterkin Signed New York Rangers Blue Adidas Jersey FANATICS COA | sportscards.com | 7279 USD | — | — |
| Ichiro Suzuki 2009 Topps Allen & Ginter Signed National Pride JSA BGS Authentic | sportscards.com | 7118 USD | — | — |
| Vince Carter Signed Toronto Raptors Custom Jersey Beckett Witness BAS COA | sportscards.com | 7118 USD | — | — |
| Connor Hellebuyck Signed Winnipeg Jets Logo Puck w/ 2025 Hart Insc. Fanatics COA | sportscards.com | 7118 USD | — | — |
| Bo Jackson Signed Autographed Auburn Tigers Custom Jersey JSA Witness COA | sportscards.com | 6976 USD | — | — |
| Johan Santana Josh Thole Signed Mets 1st No-Hitter Season Ticket Ins PSA 10 Auto | sportscards.com | 6499 USD | — | — |