| Dark Enchantress Cookie (115) (EXR) [BS10-BS11 - BS11-115] | wolfdentcg.com | 248.74 USD | — | — |
| Hollyberry Cookie (024) (EXR) [BS10-BS11 - BS10-024] | wolfdentcg.com | 159.98 USD | — | — |
| Silent Salt Cookie (122) (SUR) [BS10-BS11 - BS10-122] | wolfdentcg.com | 127 USD | — | — |
| Eternal Sugar Cookie (049) (SUR) [BS10-BS11 - BS10-049] | wolfdentcg.com | 98.74 USD | — | — |
| Avatar of Destiny (SUR) [BS10-BS11 - BS11-091] | wolfdentcg.com | 54.98 USD | — | — |
| Silent Salt Cookie (122) (SUR) (BS10-122) - The Dark Enchantress War Foil | 203collectibles.com | 52 CAD | — | — |
| Venom Dough Cookie (SSR) [BS10-BS11 - BS11-113] | wolfdentcg.com | 49 USD | — | — |
| Pomegranate Cookie (SSR) [BS10-BS11 - BS11-114] | wolfdentcg.com | 39.96 USD | — | — |
| Sugarfly Cookie (SSR) [BS10-BS11 - BS10-046] | wolfdentcg.com | 37.59 USD | — | — |
| Silent Salt Cookie (122) [BS10-BS11 - BS10-122] | wolfdentcg.com | 30.36 USD | — | — |
| Dark Enchantress Cookie (115) [BS10-BS11 - BS11-115] | wolfdentcg.com | 26.08 USD | — | — |
| Elder Faerie Cookie (SSR) [BS10-BS11 - BS10-072] | wolfdentcg.com | 23.46 USD | — | — |
| Manju Cookie [BS10-BS11] | wolfdentcg.com | 17.96 USD | — | — |
| Avatar of Destiny [BS10-BS11 - BS11-091] | wolfdentcg.com | 17.11 USD | — | — |
| Dark Cacao Cookie (SSR) (BS11-087) - The Dark Enchantress War Foil | 203collectibles.com | 16.91 CAD | — | — |
| Venom Dough Cookie [BS10-BS11 - BS11-113] | wolfdentcg.com | 14.85 USD | — | — |
| Manju Cookie (SUR) (BS10-097) - The Dark Enchantress War Foil | 203collectibles.com | 14.8 CAD | — | — |
| Shadow Milk Cookie [BS10-BS11 - BS11-071] | wolfdentcg.com | 14.28 USD | — | — |
| Salt Cellar Cookie (120) [BS10-BS11 - BS10-120] | wolfdentcg.com | 13.95 USD | — | — |
| Burning Spice Cookie [BS10-BS11 - BS11-018] | wolfdentcg.com | 13.88 USD | — | — |
| Mystic Flour Cookie [BS10-BS11 - BS11-053] | wolfdentcg.com | 12.69 USD | — | — |
| Hollyberry Cookie (017) [BS10-BS11 - BS11-017] | wolfdentcg.com | 12.28 USD | — | — |
| Salt Cellar Cookie (120) (SSR) (BS10-120) - The Dark Enchantress War Foil | 203collectibles.com | 11.8 CAD | — | — |
| Lime Cookie [BS10-BS11 - BS10-095] | wolfdentcg.com | 10.08 USD | — | — |
| Pavlova Cookie (047) [BS10-BS11 - BS10-047] | wolfdentcg.com | 9.99 USD | — | — |
| Wind Archer Cookie [BS10-BS11 - BS11-052] | wolfdentcg.com | 8.99 USD | — | — |
| Dark Cacao Cookie [BS10-BS11 - BS11-087] | wolfdentcg.com | 8.97 USD | — | — |
| Pom-pom Dough Cookie (SEC) [BS10-BS11 - BS11-112] | wolfdentcg.com | 8.89 USD | — | — |
| Nutmeg Tiger Cookie (SEC) [BS10-BS11 - BS11-014] | wolfdentcg.com | 7.99 USD | — | — |
| Mold Dough Cookie (SEC) [BS10-BS11 - BS11-111] | wolfdentcg.com | 7.81 USD | — | — |
| Wind Archer Cookie (SSR) (BS11-052) - The Dark Enchantress War Foil | 203collectibles.com | 7.3 CAD | — | — |
| Pomegranate Cookie [BS10-BS11 - BS11-114] | wolfdentcg.com | 5 USD | — | — |
| Salt Cellar Cookie (085) (SEC) [BS10-BS11 - BS11-085] | wolfdentcg.com | 4.95 USD | — | — |
| Soul Jam: Light of Silence [BS10-BS11 - BS10-119] | wolfdentcg.com | 4.72 USD | — | — |
| Silverbell Cookie (070) (SEC) [BS10-BS11 - BS10-070] | wolfdentcg.com | 4.54 USD | — | — |
| Millennial Tree Cookie [BS10-BS11 - BS11-035] | wolfdentcg.com | 4.34 USD | — | — |
| Grapefruit Cookie (SSR) (BS10-096) - The Dark Enchantress War Foil | 203collectibles.com | 4.3 CAD | — | — |
| Orange Cookie (SEC) (BS10-093) - The Dark Enchantress War Foil | 203collectibles.com | 4.3 CAD | — | — |
| Elder Faerie Cookie [BS10-BS11 - BS10-072] | wolfdentcg.com | 4.14 USD | — | — |
| Wildberry Cookie (023) [BS10-BS11 - BS10-023] | wolfdentcg.com | 3.88 USD | — | — |