| Acetomodena Extracecchio 25 yr Balsamic | waterwitchgrocer.com | 115.99 USD | — | — |
| Partanna Robust Extra Virgin Olive Oil | waterwitchgrocer.com | 33.99 USD | — | — |
| Partanna Robust Extra Virgin Olive Oil | waterwitchgrocer.com | 29.99 USD | — | — |
| Colavita Extra Virgin Olive Oil-Limited Edition | waterwitchgrocer.com | 27.99 USD | — | — |
| Cobram Estate 100% California Extra Virgin Olive Oil | waterwitchgrocer.com | 25.99 USD | — | — |
| Creminelli Fine Meats Calabrese & Finocchiona | waterwitchgrocer.com | 24.99 USD | — | — |
| Acetomodena White Balsamic with Mustard Seed | waterwitchgrocer.com | 23.99 USD | — | — |
| Cafe Grumpy Colombia Santa Maria | waterwitchgrocer.com | 19.99 USD | — | — |
| O California Extra Virgin Olive Oil Organic | waterwitchgrocer.com | 19.99 USD | — | — |
| Cafe Grumpy Heartbreaker | waterwitchgrocer.com | 19.99 USD | — | — |
| La Belle Organic B/S Chicken Breast | waterwitchgrocer.com | 18.99 USD | — | — |
| O California Fresh Basil Olive Oil | waterwitchgrocer.com | 17.99 USD | — | — |
| White Gold Parmigiano Reggiano | waterwitchgrocer.com | 16.99 USD | — | — |
| Kimono Mom's Umami Sauce | waterwitchgrocer.com | 16.99 USD | — | — |
| Dutch Gold Organic Honey | waterwitchgrocer.com | 16.99 USD | — | — |
| Acetomodena Condimento Raspberry | waterwitchgrocer.com | 15.99 USD | — | — |
| Guittard Extra Dark Chocolate Dairy Free Chips | waterwitchgrocer.com | 15.99 USD | — | — |
| Watermelon | waterwitchgrocer.com | 14.99 USD | — | — |
| Wiseways Herbals All Heal Salve | waterwitchgrocer.com | 14.99 USD | — | — |
| Shady Maple Farms 100% Pure Organic Maple Syrup | waterwitchgrocer.com | 14.99 USD | — | — |
| Desert Essence Manuka Oil & Tea Tree Skin Ointment | waterwitchgrocer.com | 14.99 USD | — | — |
| Hot Fudge For Bears | waterwitchgrocer.com | 13.99 USD | — | — |
| SO Ground Black Pepper | waterwitchgrocer.com | 13.99 USD | — | — |
| Chef Ray Sheehan Hot Honey | waterwitchgrocer.com | 13.99 USD | — | — |
| Momofuku Hot Honey Chili Crunch | waterwitchgrocer.com | 13.99 USD | — | — |
| Uncle Matt's Ultimate Defense Orange, Pineapple & Ginger Juice | waterwitchgrocer.com | 13.99 USD | — | — |
| Bubbie's Kosher Dill Pickle Chips | waterwitchgrocer.com | 12.99 USD | — | — |
| Bubbie's Spicy Kosher Dill Pickle Chips | waterwitchgrocer.com | 12.99 USD | — | — |
| Origin Creamery Regenerative Organic Certified Gouda | waterwitchgrocer.com | 12.99 USD | — | — |
| Wild Brine Probiotic Raw Organic Kraut | waterwitchgrocer.com | 12.99 USD | — | — |
| Carbone Fra Diavolo | waterwitchgrocer.com | 12.99 USD | — | — |
| Carbone Cacciatore | waterwitchgrocer.com | 12.99 USD | — | — |
| Ayoh! Original Mayo Sando Sauce | waterwitchgrocer.com | 12.99 USD | — | — |
| Carbone Bolognese | waterwitchgrocer.com | 12.99 USD | — | — |
| Ayoh! Foods Tangy Dijonayo Sando Sauce | waterwitchgrocer.com | 12.99 USD | — | — |
| Frontier Co-op Organic Prime Cuts Salt & Pepper | waterwitchgrocer.com | 11.99 USD | — | — |
| Zoup Chicken Base | waterwitchgrocer.com | 11.99 USD | — | — |
| Carbone Alfredo | waterwitchgrocer.com | 11.99 USD | — | — |
| Zoup Savory Vegan Broth | waterwitchgrocer.com | 11.99 USD | — | — |
| Nichols Farms Cocoa Cookie No Shell Pistachios | waterwitchgrocer.com | 11.99 USD | — | — |